Outrageous Traditional Ice Cream
BLUEBERRY MUFFIN ICE CREAM
We take freshly baked warm blueberry muffins and carefully smash them into Proper’s all-natural artisan ice cream. We then add our own homemade blueberry compote to create a gourmet dessert experience with creamy ice cream, chewy muffin chunks, and sweet and tart fresh blueberries throughout.
INGREDIENTS– Whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, fresh blueberries, blueberry concentrate, whole wheat flour, baking flour, yeast, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
KEY LIME PIE ICE CREAM
We dare you to try our Proper signature Key Lime Pie! Chef Rickey obsessed over a recipe that will satisfy any and every fan of the pie itself. With homemade meringue, freshly baked graham crust, and all-natural ice cream infused with bursts of Nellie’s Key Lime Juice flavor, our Key Lime Pie is truly a Proper homemade dessert experience.
INGREDIENTS– Whole milk, cream, cane sugar, sugar, skimmed milk powder, sweetened condensed milk, coconut oil, wheat flour, molasses, corn syrup, honey, lime juice. extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt, soy.
Deep Chocolate Ice Cream
It takes superior premium ingredients to create each batch of Proper’s Deep Chocolate Ice Cream. After an exhaustive worldwide search, Chef Rickey selected Valhrona Cocoa Powder and locally made 5150 Chocolate. By combining the exotic Cocoa Powder and chocolate in exact proportions, we deliver a rich deep experience to be savored by chocolate lovers of all ages.
INGREDIENTS– Whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, bananas, whole wheat flour, baking flour, butter, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt
Banana Two-Pound Cake and Cream Ice Cream
Our Banana Two-Pound Cake and Cream is made with creamy fresh banana ice cream swirled with house-made vanilla cream and rich buttery two-pound cake. Proper Ice Cream calls it two-pound cake because we double up on butter and sugars resulting in a very dense and flavorful pound cake.
INGREDIENTS– Whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, orange juice, orange concentrate, vanilla bean, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
Vanilla Malt with Roasted White Chocolate Ice Cream
Our Vanilla Malt with Roasted White Chocolate is made with Madagascar Vanilla and old-fashioned malt and mixed with roasted Valhrona white chocolate.
INGREDIENTS– Whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, non-fat dry milk powder, Madagascar vanilla beans,, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
Dark Coffee with Peanut Butter Crunch Ice Cream
We combine the richest Brazilian Roasted Coffee with an Expresso Powder to create a strong creamy base ice cream. Then, we mix and stir in some incredibly sweet Peanut Butter Crunch with hot Fudge to contrast the strong coffee and sweet peanut butter flavors with an enormously satisfying crunch.
INGREDIENTS– Whole milk, 36% heavy cream, cane sugar, sugar, nonfat dry milk powder,100% black cocoa powder, dark chocolate 90% cocoa, vanilla bean, coconut oil, extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt.
Butterscotch Cocoa Brownie
We start with our own homemade Butterscotch that is slowly layered into our sweet cream Proper base, and then we add massive chunks of freshly baked Cocoa Brownies to make this instant classic.
We source locally grown fresh mint – you could say it’s grown in our own backyard. After a thorough handwashing, we carefully cut the fresh mint by hand with scissors into a freshly made batch of Proper Ice Cream. We allow the fresh cut mint to soak for at least 24 hours so the flavor can be released and absorbed into the small batch of ice cream. The final taste and quality can only be described as “Mint Condition.”
Elevating a classic is what distinguishes Proper’s all-natural hand-crafted ice cream from the rest. Our small batch ice cream is thicker but lighter, creamier yet smoother, sweeter but not too sweet. You can experience the rich natural vanilla flavor in our clean cold ice cream with a texture and taste that melts in your mouth.
Our truly decadent dessert combines Proper’s all-natural cream base with partially baked still gooey chocolate chip cookie dough, heaps of cookie butter, and generous swirls of brown sugar to create a mouth pleasing chewy mental meltdown!
It takes local honey, a hot stove, and a lot of love to make each batch of homemade Honeycomb. It would almost be a crime to cover it up – with anything other than Proper’s small batch chocolate made with Valhrona Cocoa Powder and locally made 5150 chocolate. The combination of Honeycomb and Chocolate make for a rich, deep, sweet taste in a truly unique ice cream flavor that must be tasted to be appreciated.
Deep roasted arabica coffee beans are steeped in our Proper signature base to create a rich creamy coffee experience guaranteed to satisfy the most avid coffee enthusiast.
Cookies & Cream
We generously pack genuine Oreo cookies into our sweet cream base and then we mix in more crushed Oreo bits to make this flavor an instant Proper Classic.
We mix our own fresh Strawberry Sauce with Homemade Yellow Cake into our rich and creamy fresh ice cream base to create a delicious, sweet, and tart dessert experience.
We mix our own fresh Strawberry Sauce into our rich and creamy fresh ice cream base to create a delicious, sweet and tart dessert experience.